Schiff stepped in again when Ratcliffe pretended to want a response from Taylor and then interrupted him and said there was no time. It’s very clear that the GOP is used to playing games with the time limits and he will have none of that.
Neat little trick…Rep Turner trying to discredit Taylor and Kent because they had not met the president. But all the ones who have had contact with T are not testifying…because they don’t want to, or prevented from doing so…
Weak…Rep Turner…you are weak.
Charlie Savage
Washington Correspondent
Turner and other Republicans attack Taylor and Kent as witnesses for not having had direct contact with Trump. Of course, Trump told those who did – Mulvaney, Pompeo, Bolton and others – not to testify.
Annie Karni
White House Correspondent
And Turner is trying to dismiss their testimonies as hearsay and opinion.
In another corner of this scandal, the Roger Stone trial is coming to a close and we could in the near future see aspects of it appearing in this inquiry:
Annie Karni
White House Correspondent
Taylor appears to be unflappable, even as Republicans imply that his testimony is wrong.
In the face of Rep Jim Jordan…who screams at him.
The GOP made a big mistake a few minutes ago – Turner admitted that the 6th amendment does NOT apply here, undermining a major GOP and Trump talking point about due process.
missed it…
Republicans - all about process, nothing on substance - That’s all I got.
One of the R’s talking point (and espicially Jordan) …there aid was never withheld, but it was and because it was exposed by Politico then the Ukrainians knew that that ‘condition’ was exposed.
Charlie Savage
Washington Correspondent
Jim Jordan’s argument is that Taylor was evidently wrong that Trump’s intent was to condition the aid release on an announcement of investigations into the Bidens, since that didn’t end up happening: Trump ultimately released the aid without an announcement. Jordan’s argument is seemingly vulnerable to the fact that circumstances significantly changed in the interim (bipartisan congressional pressure, the filing of the whistleblower complaint). So it’s interesting that Jordan is opting with that tactic, rather than arguing that there would be nothing wrong with Trump conditioning aid on the announcement.
We also now know that it was John Bolton who released that aid. I wonder when that will come up.
A Mulvaney-type question OMG or State department witness perhaps.
Bloomberg reported on Saturday that though Trump claims he had unfrozen funds for the aid on September 11 after Sen. Rob Portman (R-OH) had begged for him to do so that day, the State Department had already quietly released the aid on Bolton’s orders several days prior. Bloomberg could not verify whether Trump had signed off on Bolton’s directive.
The department reportedly released the aid after White House lawyers found that Trump and the Office of Management and Budget could not legally delay it, a finding the lawyers had made earlier in 2019. According to Bloomberg, the lawyers detailed the finding in a classified memo to Secretary of State Mike Pompeo.
An unnamed source told Bloomberg that White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney was blindsided by Bolton’s order.
This is universally true…we are all in our own echo chambers.
Michael S. Schmidt
Washington Correspondent
Whatever you think of today’s testimony, it shows the problem when politics is brought into fact finding. One side sees the evidence one way. The other sees it another. Many Americans probably believe that the lawmakers made up their minds before the first witness testified.
I officially love Rep. Welch pushing back against Gym Jordan’s attack on the whistleblower: “I’d love to have the person who started it all come and testify, Trump can take a seat right there.”
Two GOP Reps have tried to slip some sort of papers or info into the hearing and gotten shut down. What’s going on with them?
Edit: A third GOP Rep tries to slip in an unrelated article after Val Demings knocks it out of the park noting how the GOP and WH are obstructing with withholding subpoenaed materials and accounts.
Seems like the GOP is trying to just slip in random articles about Obama and Clinton with no relation to the situation.
Here we go. They’re bringing up the fact that the whistleblower report came out before the release.
And now the GOP are being idiots and trying to claim Mulvaney said there was no quid pro quo, ignoring that he also said THERE WAS QUID PRO QUO on live TV. And are again pushing the conspiracy theories that Trump is being impeached for.
And Schiff gets the last word: the aid was released within 48 hours of the WH learning that Congress would definitely become aware of the situation through the whistleblower and he does NOT know who the whistleblower is.
Now THIS is a perfect conversation.
EDIT: Last bit – The GOP just tried to force a vote to subpoena the whistleblower; it got tabled, 13-9, because, again, it’s illegal and an attempt to harass the whistleblower.
Cross-posting
Summary of Impeachment Inquiry into Trump 2019
What’s new this week? All of this…
November 5th -13th News:
- 09/05/19 Trump tries to force Ukraine to meddle in the 2020 election
- 11/05/19 Sondland changes testimony, acknowledges delivering quid pro quo message to Ukraine
- 11/05/19 Sondland reverses himself on Ukraine, confirming quid pro quo
- 11/05/19 Sondland Updates Impeachment Testimony, Describing Ukraine Quid Pro Quo
- 11/05/19 Key diplomat changes testimony and admits quid pro quo with Ukraine
- 11/05/19 Graham won’t read newly released transcripts; White House plays down importance of Volker, Sondland testimony
- 11/05/19 5 takeaways from the Gordon Sondland and Kurt Volker testimonies
- 11/05/19 Key Excerpts From Sondland’s and Volker’s Testimonies in the Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/05/19 Read Gordon Sondland’s revised testimony in the impeachment probe about Trump’s pressure on Ukraine
- 11/05/19 House Democrats ask White House chief of staff Mick Mulvaney to testify in Trump impeachment probe
- 11/05/19 Impeachment investigators ask Mick Mulvaney to testify
- 11/05/19 House Democrats call on Mick Mulvaney to give deposition in impeachment probe; WH signals he won’t comply
- 11/05/19 Inside Adam Schiff’s Impeachment Game Plan
- 11/05/19 Pence aide likely to testify in impeachment inquiry
- 11/05/19 Trump wanted Barr to hold news conference saying the president broke no laws in call with Ukrainian leader
- 11/06/19 Attorney General Declined Trump Request to Declare Nothing Illegal in Ukraine Call
- 11/06/19 House Intelligence Committee Announces First Week of Open Hearings With William Taylor, George Kent and Marie Yovanovitch
- 11/06/19 Senate Republicans consider including Bidens in Trump impeachment trial
- 11/06/19 Committees Release Ambassador Bill Taylor’s Deposition Transcript as Part of Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/06/19 4 big takeaways from Bill Taylor’s full transcript
- 11/06/19 White House adds Pam Bondi to communications team to deal with impeachment investigation
- 11/06/19 Behind the Deal That Put Giuliani Together With a Dirt-Hunting Partner
- 11/06/19 New York lawyer is source of $500,000 paid to Trump attorney Giuliani
- 11/06/19 Intel officials want CIA Director Gina Haspel to protect Ukraine whistleblower from Trump
- 11/07/19 Pence aide who was concerned about July 25 call testifying Thursday
- 11/07/19 Bolton Just Ghosted on His Impeachment Hearing
- 11/07/19 Bolton willing to defy White House and testify if court clears the way, according to people familiar with his views
- 11/07/19 Impeachment investigators pressing forward without John Bolton
- 11/07/19 Republicans shrug off growing evidence, stand with Trump against impeachment
- 11/07/19 Ukraine aid was reportedly released just 2 days before Zelensky was set to announce a Burisma investigation
- 11/07/19 This is how close Trump’s plan came to working
- 11/07/19 Ukrainian President Was Booked to Announce Biden Investigation on CNN, Says Report
- 11/07/19 Ukraine’s Zelensky Bowed to Trump’s Demands, Until Luck Spared Him
- 11/07/19 Oversight Dem says ‘quid pro quo’ term might obscure Dems’ case against Trump
- 11/07/19 Committees Release George Kent’s Deposition Transcript as Part of Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/07/19 State Dept. official believed Trump-Ukraine conduct was ‘injurious to the rule of law,’ transcripts show
- 11/07/19 ‘Campaign of lies’: What George Kent told impeachment investigators
- 11/07/19 Official testifies Trump wanted Ukraine’s Zelensky to mention “Clinton”
- 11/07/19 Trump’s demands of Ukraine came down to three words: ‘Investigations, Biden and Clinton,’ official’s testimony states
- 11/07/19 Ukraine Pressure Campaign Undermined ‘Rule Of Law,’ Top State Dept. Official Says
- 11/07/19 Impeachment probe turns to Pence adviser who heard Trump’s call with Ukrainian leader
- 11/07/19 Aide From Pence Office Testifies In Impeachment Probe
- 11/07/19 The Trump Impeachment Inquiry: What Happened Today
- 11/07/19 Congressional Watchdog Reviewing Hold on Ukraine Aid
- 11/07/19 Lindsey Graham trashes Gordon Sondland after Trump ally switches tune on quid pro quo with Ukraine
- 11/07/19 Jordan: Republicans to subpoena whistleblower to testify in public hearing
- 11/07/19 Democrats unveil 3 questions to guide public impeachment hearings
- 11/07/19 Scoop: House committees subpoena Mick Mulvaney
- 11/08/19 Mulvaney defies House subpoena, cites immunity ‘one minute’ before deposition
- 11/08/19 Mick Mulvaney defies subpoena to testify in impeachment inquiry
- 11/08/19 Mick Mulvaney refuses to comply with House subpoena and doesn’t show up for impeachment deposition
- 11/08/19 Mick Mulvaney defies subpoena, skips impeachment deposition
- 11/08/19 Committees Release Vindman and Hill Transcripts as Part of Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/08/19 Ukraine expert who listened to Trump’s call says ‘there was no doubt’ the president was seeking investigations of political rivals
- 11/08/19 ‘There was no ambiguity’: What Alexander Vindman told House impeachment investigators
- 11/08/19 Lawyer for Ukraine whistleblower sends White House cease and desist letter to stop Trump’s attacks
- 11/08/19 Bolton Knows About ‘Many Relevant Meetings’ on Ukraine, Lawyer Says
- 11/08/19 Vindman says Mulvaney coordinated plan to push Ukraine for Biden investigations
- 11/08/19 Giuliani associates pressed past president of Ukraine to announce Biden investigation in exchange for state visit
- 11/08/19 Giuliani Associates Urged Ukraine’s Prior President to Open Biden, Election Probes
- 11/08/19 Trump and Giuliani remain in touch as impeachment drama heats up
- 11/08/19 House Republicans add Jordan to Intel panel for impeachment probe
- 11/08/19 Republicans want Hunter Biden, Ukraine whistleblower as impeachment inquiry witnesses
- 11/09/19 State Department Freed Ukraine Money Before Trump Says He Did
- 11/09/19 Report: State Dept. found WH had no legal ground to block Ukraine aid
- 11/09/19 Only 3 Senate Republicans aren’t defending Trump from the impeachment inquiry. Here’s why.
- 11/09/19 AP sources: Former Trump adviser John Bolton has a book deal
- 11/09/19 Trump says White House will release transcript of another call with Ukraine ‘probably’ Tuesday
- 11/09/19 In Seeking to Join Suit Over Subpoena Power, Mulvaney Goes Up Against the President
- 11/09/19 Mulvaney asks to join lawsuit over conflicting demands for impeachment testimony
- 11/10/19 Mulvaney’s move to join impeachment testimony lawsuit rankles Bolton allies
- 11/10/19 Giuliani Associate Says He Gave Demand for Biden Inquiry to Ukrainians
- 11/10/19 GOP congressman: If ‘murderers’ and ‘rapists’ get due process, Trump should too
- 11/10/19 Ukrainians Contacted U.S. Officials in May About Aid Fears
- 11/11/19 Broadcast, cable news networks to preempt regular programming for Trump impeachment coverage
- 11/12/19 Trump can’t sue New York state in DC federal court to stop release of tax returns, judge says
- 11/11/19 Judge tosses Trump suit over New York tax returns, rejects conspiracy claim
- 11/11/19 U.S. judge rules Trump suit to block House from getting his state tax returns belongs in court in N.Y.
- 11/11/19 The shallow state that drove Trump’s Ukraine policy from the outside
- 11/11/19 Committees Release Laura Cooper’s Transcript as Part of Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/11/19 Committees Release Croft and Anderson Transcripts as Part of Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/11/19 Democrats release transcripts of testimony from three officials ahead of first impeachment inquiry public hearing
- 11/11/19 Pentagon official testifies that she was told Ukrainians were alarmed by stalled aid
- 11/11/19 Pentagon official testifies White House directed freeze on aid to Ukraine
- 11/11/19 ‘Alarm bells’: What Cooper, Croft and Anderson told impeachment investigators
- 11/11/19 Trump’s plan to shrink NSC staff draws fire
- 11/11/19 After boost from Perry, backers got huge gas deal in Ukraine
- 11/11/19 Feud Between Trump Advisers Underscores a White House Torn by Rivalries
- 11/11/19 Mick Mulvaney withdraws attempt to join suit over impeachment testimony
- 11/12/19 Trump Has Considered Firing Intelligence Community Inspector General
- 11/12/19 Mick Mulvaney: A perfect conduit for Trump’s alleged Ukraine scheme
- 11/12/19 Rep. Adam Schiff: Trump’s Potentially Impeachable Offenses Include Bribery
- 11/12/19 Impeachment investigators slate open hearings for 8 more witnesses next week
- 11/12/19 At donor dinner, Giuliani associate said he discussed Ukraine with Trump, according to people familiar with his account
- 11/13/19 Key Moments From the First Public Impeachment Hearing
- 11/13/19 Live updates: Trump asked E.U. ambassador about status of Ukrainian ‘investigations,’ diplomat reveals in new testimony
- 11/13/19 Democrats land damning new evidence in impeachment testimony
- 11/13/19 Impeachment Investigators Hold First Public Hearing—Live Analysis
- 11/13/19 Taylor says staffer overheard Trump ask Sondland about ‘the investigations’
- 11/13/19 Taylor’s bombshell and 12 more big impeachment hearing moments
- 11/13/19 Scoop: House committees request new testimony from U.S. official in Ukraine
- 11/13/19 House Intel panel announces additional witnesses for public impeachment hearings
- 11/13/19 Trump says he’s not watching impeachment hearing — then critiques it
- 11/13/19 Trump: I’m ‘too busy’ to watch impeachment hearings
- 11/13/19 Rudy Giuliani’s Op-Ed Defense Of Donald Trump Backfires Spectacularly
Documents:
Just in case you want to print them all out and roll around in them, like Demi Moore from that one movie.
- 11/06/19 Testimony of Ambassador Taylor from 10/22/19
- 11/07/19 Testimony of Deputy Assistant Secretary Kent from 10/15/19
- 11/08/19 Public Document Clearinghouse: Ukraine Impeachment Inquiry
- 11/08/19 Testimony of Lieutenant Colonel Alexander Vindman from 10/29/19
- 11/08/19 Testimony of Dr. Fiona Hill from 10/14/19
- 11/08/19 Letter from Nunes to Chairman Schiff
- 11/10/19 Schiff sends letter to Republicans saying whistleblower testimony is ‘redundant and unnecessary’
- 11/11/19 Testimony of Deputy Assistant Secretary Laura Cooper from 10/23/19
- 11/11/19 Testimony of Catherine Croft from 10/30/19
- 11/11/19 Testimony of Christopher Anderson from 10/30/19
- 11/12/19 READ: Democrats circulate memo pushing back on GOP impeachment talking points
- 11/13/19 Adam Schiff’s opening statement
- 11/13/19 Devin Nunes’ opening statement
- 11/13/19 George Kent’s opening statement
- 11/13/19 Bill Taylor’s opening statement
Closed Door Hearings:
- 10/04/19 Appeared - Michael Atkinson, the Inspector General of the intelligence community
Closed Door Depositions:
Updated with more even testimonies than before!
- 10/03/19 Appeared - Kurt Volker, a former Trump administration envoy to Ukraine
- 10/07/19 Blocked - George P. Kent, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State
- 10/08/19 Blocked - Gordon Sondland, the ambassador to the European Union
- 10/08/19 Blocked - T. Ulrich Brechbuhl, State Department counselor
- 10/10/19 Requested more time - Lev Parnas, an associate of Trump lawyer Rudolph W. Giuliani
- 10/11/19 Testified - Ambassador Marie “Masha” Yovanovitch, who was removed from Ukraine by the Trump administration.
- 10/11/19 Requested more time - Igor Fruman, an associate of Rudolph W. Giuliani
- 10/14/19 Cooperating - Semyon “Sam” Kislin, an associate of Trump attorney Rudolph W. Giuliani
- 10/14/19 Appeared - Fiona Hill, the former National Security Council Russia adviser
- 10/15/19 Appeared - George P. Kent, Deputy Assistant Secretary of State
- 10/16/19 Appeared - Michael McKinley, former senior adviser to Secretary of State Michael Pompeo
- 10/17/19 Appeared - Gordon Sondland, the ambassador to the European Union
- Prepared Remarks
- Full Transcript, including an addendum he filed on November 4, 2019
- Key Excerpts
- 10/18/19 Rescheduled - Laura Cooper, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense
- 10/22/19 Appeared - William “Bill” Taylor, State Department official
- 10/23/19 Appeared - Laura Cooper, Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense
- 10/23/19 Postponed - Philip Reeker, the acting assistant secretary for European and Eurasian Affairs
- 10/23/19 Blocked - Michael Duffey, associate director for national security programs at the White House Office of Management and Budget
Note: All depositions for Oct. 24 and 25 had been postponed due to services for the late former House Oversight Committee Chairman Elijah Cummings (D-Md.)
- 10/24/19 Postponed - Alexander Vindman, the National Security Council director for European Affairs and an expert on Ukraine
- 10/24/19 Postponed - Kathryn Wheelbarger, the acting assistant secretary for international security affairs
- 10/25/19 Postponed - Suriya Jayanti, a foreign service officer stationed in Kyiv who specialized in energy issues
- 10/25/19 Refused - Russell Vought, White House Office of Management and Budget acting director
- 10/26/19 Appeared - Philip Reeker, the acting assistant secretary for European and Eurasian Affairs
- 10/28/19 Refused/filed a lawsuit - Charles Kupperman, former Deputy National Security Adviser to John Bolton
- 10/29/19 Appeared - Lt. Col. Alexander S. Vindman, European affairs director at the National Security Council
- 10/30/19 Appeared - Catherine Croft, State Department Ukraine expert
- 10/30/19 Appeared - Christopher Anderson, State Department Ukraine expert
- 10/30/19 - Refused - Kathryn Wheelbarger, the acting assistant secretary for international security affairs
- 10/31/19 Appeared - Timothy Morrison, the former senior director for Russian affairs at the National Security Council
- 10/04/19 Refused - Robert Blair, a senior adviser to acting White House Chief of Staff Mick Mulvaney
- 10/04/19 Refused - Brian McCormack, director of natural resources, energy and science at the White House Office of Management and Budget
- 10/04/19 Blocked - John Eisenberg, National Security Council lawyer
- 10/04/19 Refused - Michael Ellis, National Security Council lawyer
Public Impeachment Hearings:
Wow, so much to watch!
- 11/13/19 Impeachment Hearing with William Taylor and George Kent
Thanks for skimming, ok, now i need a nap
Timeline has been updated. Breaking news starts below.
OMG this group brings more news than a fish monger!
Dumb joke but I see a couple of user created well-cited timelines of different calls and events, I have bookmarked those and that’ll be the next thing I try and figure out how to format and integrate into our massive Trump impeachment wiki. Thanks for posting those, they will not be forgotten.
Appeals court hands Trump another loss, saying Congress can seek his tax returns
An appeals court has denied for the second time President Donald Trump’s attempt to stop an accounting firm from turning over his financial documents to the House, making it the second tax case Trump’s lawyers say they are taking to the Supreme Court.
The DC Circuit Court of Appeals said on Wednesday that a panel of eight judges out of 11 voted against allowing Trump to continue his appeal.
The decision is another loss stacked against Trump, after federal judges have repeatedly rebuked him and greenlighted the House’s effort as it also pursues his impeachment. The case, if Trump loses again with the Supreme Court, could deliver his tax returns or closely related financial documents into the hands of House Democrats.
The opinion reiterates the strong signal the court sent last month, when it upheld a lower court ruling that Trump’s longtime accounting firm Mazars USA must comply with a House subpoena of his tax documents and turn over eight years of accounting records.
Trump’s attorney Jay Sekulow said Wednesday that they will appeal the decision to Supreme Court, noting “well reasoned dissent” from three judges to Wednesday’s opinion.
Three out of eleven judges.
More,
Each new revelation is welcome in the face of the obstruction coming from T 'n co…